Investigation 5

Photosynthesis

What factors affect the rate of photosynthesis in living leaves?

Unit 3: Cellular EnergeticsENE-1.IENE-1.JScience Practice 6.B≈ 3–4 class periodsAbout 130 minutes in total
Overview

What you'll investigate

Photosynthesis is hard to watch directly, but a cheap trick makes it visible. Punch small disks from a leaf, pull the air out of them so they sink, and put them under a lamp in a bicarbonate solution. As the disks make oxygen, they float back up. How fast they rise tells you how fast net photosynthesis is going.

First you will learn the floating leaf disk assay: infiltrating disks with a syringe, counting floating disks each minute, and summarizing a trial with the ET50, the estimated time for 50% of the disks to float. Then you will design your own experiment that tests light intensity, light color, CO2 supply, temperature, or a leaf feature.

Learning objectives
  • ENE-1.I Describe the photosynthetic processes that allow organisms to capture and store energy.
  • ENE-1.J Explain how cells capture energy from light and transfer it to biological molecules for storage and use.
Science practice
  • 6.B Support a claim with evidence from biological principles, concepts, processes, and/or data.

You will also practice building indices (ET50), using reciprocals to replot data, and using medians and ±2 SE error bars to show variability.

Safety in the real lab

Wear goggles and an apron. You will work close to hot, exposed lightbulbs: keep solutions and wet hands away from bulbs and electrical cords, since a drip can shatter a hot bulb. Do not lean on lamps. Test your syringes before use, because some fail under vacuum. If you study temperature, never heat a solution above 50–60 °C.

Background

Measuring photosynthesis with buoyancy

Key ideas
  • Leaf disks float because the spongy mesophyll is full of air. A vacuum replaces that gas with solution, so the disks sink.
  • In the light, with bicarbonate as a CO2 source, photosynthesis puts O2 back into the air spaces and the disks rise.
  • Respiration uses some of that O2 at the same time, so rising disks measure net photosynthesis.
  • ET50 is the time for half the disks to float. A faster rate gives a smaller ET50, so 1/ET50 is used as the rate.
  • For a small lamp, light intensity falls roughly with the square of the distance (an approximation), and chlorophyll absorbs red and blue light far better than green.

In photosynthesis, chloroplasts capture light energy and use it to make carbohydrate from CO2 and water, releasing O2:

2 H2O + CO2 + light → (CH2O) + O2 + H2O
Light reactions, the Calvin cycle and the leaf

In the light reactions, pigments in the thylakoid membranes absorb photons. The energy splits water, releasing O2, and drives the production of ATP and NADPH. In the Calvin cycle, the enzyme rubisco fixes CO2, and ATP and NADPH power its reduction to sugar. For every CO2 fixed, one O2 is released, so a mole of glucose (C6H12O6) means six moles of O2. You could measure either CO2 used or O2 made. This lab tracks O2.

Upper epidermis Palisade layer Spongy mesophyll (air spaces) Stoma
Why the disks sink and rise

The spongy mesophyll is full of air spaces, so leaf disks normally float. If you hold a disk under vacuum in a syringe of solution, the gas is pulled out of those spaces. When the vacuum is released, liquid floods in. The disk is now denser than the solution and sinks. A drop of dilute soap acts as a wetting agent so the solution can get past the waxy leaf surface.

The solution contains sodium bicarbonate (HCO3−), which gives the chloroplasts a supply of CO2. In the light, photosynthesis releases O2 into the air spaces. Bubbles build up until the disk becomes buoyant and rises. But leaf cells have mitochondria too. Cellular respiration uses some of that O2 at the same time. Rising disks therefore measure net photosynthesis (gross photosynthesis minus respiration). In the dark, respiration alone slowly uses up the trapped O2, and floating disks sink again.

Fresh disk: gas-filled, floats After vacuum: sinks Light + HCO₃⁻: O₂ builds, rises
Turning floating disks into a rate

Every minute you count how many disks are floating. Disks do not all rise together, and once in a while one never rises, so the median time is a better summary than the mean. The ET50 is the time when half the disks are floating. You can read it off the floating-versus-time graph by linear interpolation between the two minutes on either side of 50%.

A faster process gives a smaller ET50, so graphing ET50 against light intensity slopes downward. Taking the reciprocal, 1/ET50 (min−1), gives a quantity that rises with the rate. Plotted against light, it makes the familiar curve that rises and then levels off.

rate ∝ 1 / ET50     light intensity ∝ 1 / (distance)2 (approximately, for a small lamp)
Light intensity and light color

For a small light source, light intensity approximately follows the inverse square law: doubling the distance spreads the light over about four times the area, so only about ¼ as many photons reach the disks. Real classroom lamps may behave differently because of their shape, reflectors, and surrounding light. The simulation uses the inverse square law as its model. Tip: if you have a light meter, measure the intensity at the cups; that is better than relying on distance. Chlorophyll a and b absorb blue and red light strongly and green light weakly, which is why leaves look green and why green light drives photosynthesis poorly.

What this simulation models
  • Process: Net photosynthesis in leaf disks. O2 made in the light collects in the air spaces until a disk floats, while respiration uses some of it.
  • Included: Light intensity from lamp distance (the inverse square model), light color (chlorophyll absorbs green poorly), bicarbonate as the CO2 supply, temperature (enzyme optimum, heat damage, lamp heating), respiration, plant type, leaf age, and disk-to-disk variation.
  • Simplified or left out: Floating is a simple O2 threshold. Solution depth, disks sticking to the cup, CO2 running low and light damage are ignored. Real lamps and filters vary, and the plant values are estimates, so bench ET50 values may differ.
Pre-lab check

Before you start

Procedure · Steps 1–6

Infiltrate the leaf disks

Before you begin: Check that the leaf disks sink after infiltration. Then begin the flotation trial and watch for disks rising.

Need a quick science reminder?

Infiltration replaces air spaces with solution. Floating before the trial may mean a disk was not fully infiltrated; follow the procedure before interpreting the results.

Controls

The soap wets the waxy cuticle so solution can enter.
Full procedure

Set up. Make 300 mL of 0.2% sodium bicarbonate and pour about 3 cm into a cup labeled "With CO2". Fill a second cup with water only and label it "Without CO2". This cup is your control. Add one drop of dilute soap to each cup, and avoid making suds. Punch 10 uniform spinach disks for each cup, avoiding big veins.

Infiltrate. Put 10 disks in each syringe, push the plunger in until less than 10% air remains, and draw up about 5 mL of the matching solution. Then cap the tip with a finger, pull back the plunger to make a vacuum for about 10 seconds while swirling, and release. This is the step that takes practice. Repeat until the disks sink, but more than three vacuums can damage them. If they still won't sink, add soap.

Vacuums applied (count)0
Sunk, with CO₂ (disks)0 / 10
Sunk, without CO₂ (disks)0 / 10
Procedure · Steps 7–9

Count floating disks and find ET50

Controls

More options
Fixed conditions

Spinach, mature leaves · 100 W-equivalent CFL lamp 15 cm above the cups (≈400 µmol photons m⁻² s⁻¹) · 0.2% NaHCO₃ · room temperature 25 °C

The table records the count at the end of each minute, just as you would.

Full procedure

Put both cups under the lamp and start the timer. At the end of each minute, count the floating disks and then swirl the cups to free any disks stuck to the sides. Keep going until every disk in the bicarbonate cup is floating. To see respiration, put a box over the cups after the disks have floated and keep counting.

Before you start: if you treat the disks in a way that increases net photosynthesis, should they float faster or slower? What do you predict for the water-only cup?

Time (min)0.0 min
Floating, with CO₂ (disks)0
Floating, without CO₂ (disks)0
LampOn

Calculate ET50 and the rate

ET50 and relative rate

ET50: time when 50% of the disks float.

Relative rate = 1 ÷ ET50 (min−1).

If 50% occurs between readings, estimate the time using the two neighboring disk counts. Shorter ET50 means faster net oxygen accumulation.

Find the two minutes on either side of half the disks floating (5 of 10) in the "With CO2" column (open the Data tab above). Interpolate: ET50 = tbefore + (half − nbefore) ÷ (nafter − nbefore). Then take the reciprocal.

Designing and conducting your investigation

Test a variable of your choice

Now that you can run the assay, choose a variable that might change the net rate of photosynthesis. It could be environmental (light intensity, color, CO2 supply, temperature) or a feature of the leaf (plant type, leaf age). Each cup holds 10 disks, and each cup gives one ET50. Use several cups per level so you can see how much results vary.

Controls

More options
Held constant

Time (min)0 min
Cups (count)—
Water temperature (°C)—
Analyzing results

Make sense of your data

Need to revisit leaf-disk flotation measurements and timing? Review the investigation steps before interpreting your results.

How do I interpret floating disks and ET50?
  1. Read the flotation trend. Compare the number or percentage of disks floating at the same elapsed times across conditions.
  2. Find ET50. Identify the time when half of the disks are floating. A shorter ET50 generally indicates faster oxygen accumulation under the tested conditions.
  3. Compare conditions. Keep disk number, leaf material, solution, and timing in mind when explaining differences. Describe what changed in your investigation.
  4. Consider limitations. Disks may infiltrate unevenly, stick to the cup, or rise at slightly different times. Explain how this affects confidence in the comparison.

Flotation is an indirect indicator of photosynthetic oxygen production; it is not a direct measurement of glucose made by the leaf.

Scientific reasoning self-check (optional)

Before submitting, review your own explanation against these checkpoints. These are reminders, not an automatic grade or an evaluation of your writing.

  • My claim compares the tested photosynthesis conditions.
  • I cite floating-disk counts or ET50 values, including time units.
  • I connect flotation to oxygen accumulation rather than claiming it directly measures glucose.
  • I identify a limitation such as uneven infiltration or differences among leaf disks.

If a checkpoint is missing, revisit your data and revise your explanation. The site does not read or score your written response here.

Evaluate and extend

Where can you go from here?

Wrap up

Save and hand in your work